2025 Loyalty Report
Is your brand tapping into these three unshakeable pillars of guest loyalty in 2025?
2 min read
3 Essential Solutions for Your Loyalty Program's Biggest Problems
Mar 22, 2018

Loyalty programs are a great way to retain customers and keep them coming back to your business time and time again. In fact, by increasing customer retention by only 5%, your brand can increase profits by 25 to 95%, which is why effective loyalty marketing strategy is an ever-more-important part of your overall marketing plan.
But there is one major problem with today’s loyalty programs – there has been a two percent decline in overall active member rates which leads to slower growth and profits for brands. What's causing this decline in active participation, and how can brands turn it around to fix this problem?
There are a couple of new insights that help shed a light on the cause of this decline and the tactics that can mitigate and even turn around loyalty programs so they are profitable and engaging to customers.
- 43% of customers say that physical loyalty card programs are their number one frustration. Customers want to enroll and engage with loyalty programs, but they have a hard time carrying another card in their wallet around with them and always remembering to bring it on their shopping trips. This problem is easy to solve. Opening your program to different ways that customers can interact with it will help increase overall activity. With the rise of smartphones, brands can engage their customers on the platform they use the most. Offer a loyalty app, link your loyalty program to mobile payments, and utilize a simple phone number to appeal to the most customers. This way they will not need to carry a card with them; they can use their phone to be active members of a program.
- Only 24% of customers understand the loyalty programs they’re enrolled in. Some brands' loyalty program designs are challenging for guests to understand. With tiers, challenges, and multiple things going on at once, it's difficult for customers to assess their progress and know how to get their next reward. It’s important to make sure all customers know what is expected of them in a loyalty program, how to get a reward, and how to redeem their rewards. There are is one rule that should apply to all loyalty programs no matter the brand – keep it simple. The easier it is for guests to understand and interact with your program the greater chance they will utilize the program.
- 65% of customers try to redeem rewards only to find out they expired. There’s nothing worse than thinking you have a reward and going to a business to use it only to realize at the checkout that the reward has expired. In fact, 56% of customer change or abandon their purchases when they found out their reward expired. This leads to frustration for your customers and can turn them off from a program and cause them to no longer shop with your brand. Luckily, there's a simple fix to this problem – send out notifications of expiring rewards so that customers have time to act and use them before they become invalid. Sending out an email to customers who have rewards that are expiring helps spur activity and keeps them with your brand.
Other Posts You Might Like

Building Blocks of a Core Program
The purpose of a rewards program is to change your customers’ behavior, getting them to visit more often and/or make more purchases.

How to Manage Your Club Programs
Club programs are a staple in the convenience store industry. They help to motivate customers to visit more often since the customer knows that...

3 Loyalty Program Secrets to Drive More Incremental Revenue
With a greater understanding of customer spending and visit habits, marketing becomes more agile, is able to make informed decisions, and can...

5 Loyalty Program Mistakes Your Brand Needs to Avoid at All Costs
Loyalty programs are all about connecting with your customers and creating a great experience for them whenever they interact with your brand.

Four Considerations when Designing a Reward Program
There are many different types of reward programs which make it challenging to choose which one is best suited for your brand. Ultimately, there are...

Dos and Don’ts of Successful Reward Programs
Most convenience stores share similar reasons for having a reward program – such as improving profitability and enticing customers to make...

5 Loyalty Program Setup Ideas for Faster Retention and Engagement
Loyalty programs can have an astounding impact on your business, increasing visits, spend, and overall revenue immediately and for years to come. ...

Are Loyalty Programs on Their Way Out?
It’s likely you don’t need to be sold on the efficacy of loyalty programs. But, just in case you need a little reminder, a recent study found that...

The Keys to High ROI for Grab-and-Go Food and Beverages
For some people, the news that both Target and Whole Foods are moving into the grab-and-go segment might feel like a threat. But for savvy c-store...

Why Club Programs Work
Club programs enjoy perennial popularity as the foundation of rewards programs. At some point, nearly every person will have had a paper or...

How to Control the Off-Premises Experience
More than ever before, customers are driven by convenience; they want what they want when they want it, and where. And, so, to keep up with...

An App is Just the Tip of the Mobile Iceberg
With 72% of U.S. adults using a smartphone, mobile technology is changing the way that brands connect with their customers. Most brands have...

Dos and Don’ts of Rolling Out a Loyalty Program
R olling out a loyalty program is a critical part of making sure you’re set up for success in the future. Capturing customers interests and getting...

Target Low-Frequency Customers. Here’s Why.
The greatest revenue-generating potential a loyalty program can tap into is a brand’s segment of customers who visit sometimes but not always. We...