Your Campaign Results Might Be Lying to You

The only way to know if your loyalty or other guest-engagement campaigns are succeeding is to track them and analyze your results. Unfortunately, even numbers that appear straightforward can contain hidden implications.

Depending on how you look at your data, a campaign can seem like a roaring success or a misfire. But sometimes it requires further analysis to determine if your initial assessments are accurate.

In worst-case scenarios, you may discover that a campaign you decide to run again based on previous positive data had been a misfire the entire time. Not only are you producing unfavorable results, but you are also wasting time, manpower, and money.

For example, let’s say you set up a “We Miss You” campaign. These are fairly common loyalty program campaigns in which you send out an offer to people who have not visited your stores in a while to encourage them to return. After deciding that you’re going to set up a campaign for people who have not visited in 60 days, you send them a coupon for 15 percent off an entrée.

Once you’ve run the campaign and examined your results, the numbers look great. Many guests who had not visited in 60 days made visits during the campaign period and used the coupon you sent them. It seems like the campaign was a resounding success!

But was it truly successful? Sometimes results in campaigns like this are deceiving. […]

What Chipotle Did Right (and Wrong) in Its First-Ever Loyalty Program

For a quite a while, Chipotle executives didn’t believe loyalty programs were for them. In fact, Mark Crumpacker, CCO/CDO of Chipotle, said in September 2015*, “We don’t believe the general supposition that loyalty will make less frequent customers more frequent.”

However, from the fourth quarter of 2015 into the early second quarter of 2016, Chipotle had a few health scares that contributed to its stock prices — and sales — to take a tumble.

In summer 2016, Chipotle was ready to rethink its stance on loyalty programs and launched its Chiptopia Summer Rewards, a three-month tiered loyalty program.

It’s reasonable to assume, based on the structure of the program (that we’ll cover next) and the business challenges they were experiencing, that
Chipotle’s motivation in creating its loyalty program was to increase visits.

Note: Before we go any further, we want to make it clear that Chipotle is not a client of Paytronix. This blog post is designed to analyze the Chiptopia program, share what worked and what didn’t, and help you think — or rethink — your own loyalty program.

The Chipotle Loyalty Program Structure: How It Worked


Kristen House Recognized with New Hospitality Technology Award for 2017 Top Women in Foodservice Technology

Three Questions with HT’s 2017 “Rising Star” Award Recipient

Today we have the honor of sharing an important award recognition bestowed upon one of our own employees. Hospitality Technology (HT) magazine has recognized Kristen House as a winner in the first annual Top Women in Foodservice Technology Awards. This program recognizes an inaugural class of women for making a significant impact in the food-service technology industry—re-imagining how things are done in restaurants while demonstrating excellence in leadership, inventiveness and skill.

As the head of messaging for Paytronix (and of mobile products before that), Kristen House has worked directly with many of our clients and partners who have experienced first-hand what impact she’s having upon their mobile strategy. Kristen has helped move multiple retailers and restaurant chains onto a multi-channel platform that has allowed them to embrace new technologies, such as geofencing and mobile messaging.

Within the company, Kristen’s recent efforts led to the development of the Paytronix Campaign Center’s survey capabilities, delivering an innovative messaging platform that enables retail and restaurant marketers to elicit feedback from their customers and quickly respond to customer sentiments and adjust their offerings accordingly.

“We were thrilled to be faced with the task of culling through so many deserving nominations of highly qualified women in the food-service technology industry,” said Dorothy Creamer, editor, HT magazine, in an article announcing the winners. “The achievements of all the nominees are truly outstanding and we will be paying attention to what the future holds for each of them.”

The HT awards were created to pay homage to women from up-and-coming innovators to high-achieving mentors who continue to inspire. Kristen has been recognized with a “Rising Star” award for demonstrating leadership and making a mark in food-service technology at an early stage in her career.

As a winner, Kristen House is profiled in this month’s March 2017 issue of Hospitality Technology. Read the feature here. She’ll also be recognized during a formal awards program at the 22nd annual Multi-Unit Restaurant Technology Conference (March 7-9, 2017 in Las Vegas).

We sat down today with Kristen for a short interview about the award. Read on for more on the mobile and technology innovations Kristen is spearheading, and for perspective on what it means to be honored with a Top Women in Foodservice Technology Award.

Michelle Tempesta:

Until recently, you were the mobile product manager at Paytronix. In this capacity you shepherded the introduction of new capabilities, such as geofencing and refer-a-friend, into the mobile platform. In just four years at the company, you built innovative features into an app that more than 65 Paytronix customers launched. What were some of the most exciting technologies you worked with in that role?

Kristen House:

We designed our mobile apps to help our clients bring a mobile experience to market efficiently, without the heavy price tag of custom applications. The apps include a larger number of features, are scalable across multiple merchants, and are updated often. I have very much enjoyed watching the apps evolve into a broader mobile platform, which includes a wide variety of mobile messaging options, hosted mobile-friendly websites, and payment capabilities.

In 2015, I helped introduce geofencing capabilities to the Paytronix app. Paytronix Geofencing enables restaurants to leverage geographic data on program members who are in the vicinity of a restaurant. As a member crosses the virtual “fence” around a specific store, the geofencing module surfaces a message to their smartphone that reminds them to use rewards they’ve earned or to come in to try their favorite drink. Because each message is integrated into the rewards platform, retailers and restaurants ensure that each offer is segmented appropriately. For example, a free coffee message will only be sent to members who have a free coffee on their account. Geofence messaging has enabled customers like the Elephant Bar restaurant chain to send messages to rewards members when they are nearby a location. In a review of three 2015 campaigns, Elephant Bar determined that approximately 30% of members visited a restaurant on the day that they received a geofencing message.

Also, in January 2016, I initiated collaboration with California Pizza Kitchen (CPK) CIO Andy Mai on the development of a next-generation CPK v2.0 mobile app. Like the previous version of the CPK app, it is integrated with the Paytronix Rewards Platform, a foundation which underlies the entire CPK Pizza Dough Rewards program.  The app also integrates directly into CPK’s Aloha cloud-based POS platform.


In your new role as messaging products manager, what new messaging innovations are you driving, and how are your clients benefiting from these new tools and associated data?


In my new role I work closely with the Paytronix install base to help them become more powerful and relevant with their messaging strategy. Managing the Paytronix Campaign Center, we provide a centralized user interface that enables users to manage all campaigns in one place. I’ve been able to enhance the combination of campaign tools, data at the user’s fingertips, and messaging options that enable marketers to learn quickly and act instantly.

Additionally, it has been a pleasure to keep infusing new value into the Paytronix messaging platform. Our new one-to-one survey suite allows marketers to elicit guest feedback within a single platform. Marketers can avoid the complications and time consumption of creating, deploying, analyzing and rewarding behavior across multiple systems. Whether triggered upon close of a check or sent in a custom campaign, this new tool set brings the customer data to the marketer more quickly. As a result, marketers can gather preferences directly from customers, build rich customer profiles, quickly respond to customer sentiments and adjust their offerings accordingly. To date, users have seen a near tenfold increase in the percentage of guest responses when compared with traditional survey calls to action typically found at the bottom of the guest’s receipt.

The Campaign Center, survey tools, white-label mobile apps, and geofencing messaging enable brands to be agile marketers – which means, they learn fast, deploy smarter campaigns, and deliver exceptional positive financial results.


This is a new award program for Hospitality Technology that celebrates the accomplishments of women who are innovators in a historically male-driven space. What does this honor mean to you?


In reality, I share this honor with the terrific colleagues who work hard to deliver the best features each day. I hope this will inspire other women to be a formidable presence in the technology space, even early on in their careers. It’s a dream come true to be recognized alongside some of the inspiring women in the field, including Anita Klopfenstein of Panera Bread and Stephanie Nardini of Jersey Mike’s.

What Are Brands Getting Wrong About Content Marketing?

An Interview with Content Marketing Professor Neil Feinstein

Content marketing professor and consultant Neil Feinstein has helped brands like Disney, American Express, and The New York Times improve their marketing efforts via social media, email, and mobile. In a recent interview, Neil provided insights from his years of experience that you can use to leverage content to bolster your own marketing efforts.

Paytronix: What are brands getting wrong about content marketing?

Neil: Too many brands align their marketing strategies with themselves, and not their customers. For a consumer interaction to be meaningful, it needs to be based on a consumer insight. What does the customer care about? Why should the customer care? Before marketers push out content, before they start tweeting or blogging or gramming, they need to understand the customer and then build a strategy that aligns with his/her expectations – not the business’s.

Paytronix: If that’s the case, what are most brands getting right about content marketing? […]